Empowering Children’s Rights

Did you know that regular recess is shown to improve children’s social skills, behavior, and academic performance? Despite its benefits, recess is often overlooked in today’s educational system, making IEP recess advocacy an essential tool for ensuring children receive the breaks they need. Growing up in the early 1970s, I was fortunate to live near a wooded area and attend a school that valued recess. As an elementary student, I enjoyed a full 45 minutes of unstructured play each day. We formed groups to play games like Red Rover, 4 Square, and Dodgeball, swung on the swings, spun on the merry-go-round, or simply walked the track. Many of these activities are no longer permitted, highlighting the importance of advocating for meaningful recess time.

My afternoons were spent in boundless play, with the natural world as our playground. As I
explored the woods I also forged friendships and alliances. We’d venture into the forests,
crafting forts and exploring until the glow of streetlights signaled the end of our adventures. In
moments of solitude, I was often found lost in the pages of a book or simply meandering to the
local store to purchase the latest X-men comic, each activity a thread in the fabric of my youthful
exploration.

This era of my childhood, where learning extended beyond the classroom into every corner of
our daily lives, formed the core of my “nature schooling”—similar to what could be described as
a ‘hunter-gatherer’ education. This term refers to how children naturally explore, learn, and
develop through direct interaction with their environment, much like early humans did. These
free-form adventures not only taught us about our environment but also instilled skills like
problem-solving, creativity, social interaction, and resilience.

However, reflecting on the shift over recent decades, as outlined in Howard Chudacoff’s
Children at Play: An American History, it’s clear that the latter half of the 20th century marked a
significant transformation. From about 1960 onwards, the landscape of childhood began to
change. The decline in unsupervised play and the increase in structured activities meant
children lost much of their freedom to explore independently.

This shift has had profound implications. Alongside the reduction in unstructured play, there has
been a notable increase in mental health issues among young people. Historical data shows a
marked rise in anxiety, depression, and even suicide rates in children and adolescents. This
stark contrast between the freedom once experienced in youth and the structured, closely
supervised lives of today’s children highlights a critical loss in the spontaneous joy and
developmental richness of unstructured play. It’s imperative that we recognize the long-term
benefits that recess and free play offer to our children’s mental and physical health. As schools
transitioned towards more structured curriculum models, recess began to be viewed as less
essential to child development, a perspective increasingly at odds with contemporary research
emphasizing its benefits.

Importance of Recess

Leading health organizations, including the American Academy of Pediatrics (APA) and the
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), advocate for children to enjoy at least 20
minutes of recess daily. Extensive research in the fields of health, public health, education, and
the social sciences supports this recommendation, highlighting the multifaceted benefits of
recess. Understanding these benefits in greater depth reveals just how crucial recess is not only
for fostering health but also for supporting educational success.

Recess not only promotes concentration and enhances academic performance, but it is also
crucial for developing key social-emotional skills like empathy, teamwork, and conflict resolution.
Engaging in unstructured play helps improve children’s executive functions and classroom
behavior, which can lead to better school attendance and a more positive school environment.
Furthermore, recess serves as an essential period for children to engage in physical activity,
contributing significantly to the recommended 60 minutes of daily exercise. In fact, neurological
studies have found a twenty-fold spike in brain activity following breaks like recess, illustrating
its critical role in cognitive processing and learning reinforcement. Yet, while the advantages of
recess are clear, not all students experience these benefits equally. Children with disabilities, in
particular, face distinct barriers that can limit their access to this vital part of the school day.
Challenges Specific to Children with Disabilities

Children with disabilities often encounter unique hurdles that can restrict their access to recess,
an essential part of the school day. These barriers can range from physical accessibility issues
to school-wide rules on behavior and educational program adjustments, which may limit their
participation in recess activities. Expanding upon these challenges, it’s essential to delve into
the insights provided by parents regarding recess barriers.

Parental Insights on Recess Challenges

In a recent Facebook poll in our IEP/504 Support & Assistance group, 500 parents reported that
schools had withheld recess from their children with an IEP or 504 plan due to behavior or other
disability-related issues. Additionally, 71 parents noted that their children lost recess time to
make up for work missed due to disability-related absences. These findings highlight a critical
gap between best practices and actual practices in schools regarding the treatment of children
with disabilities. Building upon these parental insights, let’s examine the common barriers that
hinder access to recess for children with disabilities.

Common Barriers

● Withholding Recess for Punishment: In some schools, behavior management policies
are applied uniformly, without consideration of individual needs. For children with
disabilities, especially those with behavioral or emotional disorders, this can mean
recess is withheld as a form of discipline or behavior management. This approach not
only deprives them of the benefits of play but can also exacerbate behavior and create
feelings of isolation or stigma.

● Unfinished Work: Often, children with learning disabilities require more time to
complete assignments or may be absent for disability-related purposes. Schools might
withhold recess as a consequence of unfinished work, disproportionately affecting these
students. This practice overlooks the benefits of recess as a crucial break that can
enhance cognitive function and academic performance.

● IEP/504 Plan Conflicts: Recess may be undervalued or overlooked in the development
of Individualized Education Plans (IEPs) or 504 plans. Consequently, this essential time
can be replaced with therapy or tutoring sessions, denying children the unstructured play
that is vital for social and emotional development.

● Physical Accessibility: Accessibility remains a significant barrier in many schools.
Without ramps, adapted equipment, or accessible playgrounds, children with physical
disabilities cannot participate fully in recess, which is against the inclusive spirit of
education.

● Accessibility for the Visually Impaired: Playgrounds often lack features like tactile
paths, audible play equipment, and clearly defined boundaries, which are crucial for the
safety and engagement of visually impaired children. Ensuring these adaptations are in
place, along with thoughtful supervision and peer integration, is essential for enabling
these students to participate fully in recess activities.

Given these common barriers, it’s imperative to explore the legal and ethical considerations
surrounding the inclusion of children with disabilities in recess activities.
Legal and Ethical Considerations

Legally, the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act,
alongside the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), mandate the inclusion of
children with disabilities in all school activities, including recess. The ADA and Section 504
collectively provide robust protections against discrimination based on disability, ensuring that
children with disabilities have equal opportunities to participate in all aspects of school life.
These laws support the right to equal participation, emphasizing that access to recess is not a
privilege but a fundamental right that upholds the dignity of every student.
Denying recess can seriously affect a child’s development. Recess is not just a break from
studying; it is a crucial part of learning social skills and maintaining mental health. Schools need
to carefully consider these ethical and legal responsibilities to create a welcoming environment
that respects every child’s right to play and learn equally. With a foundation in the legal and
ethical framework, let’s now delve into the significant impact of missing recess on children with
disabilities.

School Barriers to Recess

Despite the recognized benefits of recess for child development, schools face significant
institutional challenges in maintaining and prioritizing recess. Often, once the initial school
construction is completed, outdoor play spaces are neglected and rarely updated, which can
lead to deteriorating conditions that are not conducive to active play. Furthermore, the pressure
to achieve high academic performance and meet standardized test benchmarks frequently
leads school administrations to deprioritize recess in favor of more in-class instructional time.
This lack of attention to maintaining outdoor play facilities, coupled with a focus on academic
outcomes, can severely impact the quality and availability of recess for students.

Moreover, the implementation of recess policies can vary significantly between schools, often
depending on the discretion of individual principals. Only 20% of elementary school principals
have implemented a mandatory recess policy across the board, which indicates a spotty and
inconsistent approach to recess across different schools. This inconsistency can create
disparities in how recess is valued and integrated into the school day, affecting students’ access
to this critical time for unstructured play and socialization.

These institutional challenges highlight the need for systemic changes and dedicated efforts to
ensure that recess is not only included but also effectively implemented as a vital component of
the school day. By addressing these challenges, schools can better support the holistic
development of all students, ensuring they receive the full spectrum of benefits that recess
offers. Considering the institutional challenges, let’s look at the impact of missing recess.

Impact of Missing Recess

The absence of recess can severely impact children with disabilities. In the short term, it may
lead to decreased engagement and increased disruptive behaviors in the classroom. Over the
long term, the lack of social interaction and physical activity can stunt emotional growth and
exacerbate existing health issues. The benefits of recess—in fostering friendships, developing
conflict resolution skills, and improving overall well-being—are too critical to overlook.
By addressing these challenges, schools can help ensure that children with disabilities receive
equitable access to the benefits of recess, supporting their right to a comprehensive and
inclusive educational experience. Having explored the impact of recess absence, let’s shift our
focus to the institutional challenges faced by schools in prioritizing and maintaining recess.

Advocacy within the IEP/504 Plan

Recess is not just a leisure activity—it is a crucial part of educational development, especially
for children with disabilities. Ensuring that recess is protected as a non-negotiable part of the
school day within Individualized Education Programs (IEPs) and 504 plans is essential.
Why Specify Recess in IEPs and 504 Plans?

Recess supports numerous developmental needs, including social skills, physical health, and
emotional resilience. For children with disabilities, these breaks are critical to managing stress,
regulating emotions, and integrating socially with peers. By making recess a required part of the
day, we prevent other academic or therapeutic activities from taking its place.

Step-by-Step Guide to Including Recess in IEP/504 Discussions

Preparation

Review your child’s needs and how recess can support their educational and developmental
goals. Gather any notes or observations about how your child interacts during recess and the
benefits they gain.

Documentation

Clearly document in the IEP or 504 plan that recess is essential for your child’s social,
emotional, and physical development. Specify the amount of time needed and the types of
activities that are beneficial.

Advocacy

During IEP/504 meetings, articulate why recess is indispensable. Use examples and evidence
to support your case. If necessary, bring in statements from healthcare providers or therapists
who can attest to the importance of recess for your child’s well-being.

Follow-Up

After the meeting, ensure that the agreed-upon recess accommodations are implemented.
Regularly check in with your child and their teachers to monitor how well the recess
accommodations are working and whether they need to be adjusted.

Annual Review

Recess needs may change as your child grows or as their needs evolve. Make sure to revisit
the discussion about recess during your annual IEP/504 plan review to adjust any details as
necessary.

By following these steps, you can effectively advocate for recess to be an integral and protected
part of your child’s educational plan, ensuring they receive the full benefits of this crucial school
activity. Expanding upon advocacy strategies, let’s explore additional ideas for incorporating
recess accommodations into IEPs and 504 plans.

Additional Ideas on Recess in the IEP/504

● Social Skills Work During Recess: For children who find it challenging to navigate
social interactions during unstructured times like recess, it may be beneficial to request
push-in services from an occupational therapist (OT) who can assist in developing these
crucial skills. During your IEP/504 meetings, consider advocating for such services to be
included during recess, ensuring your child receives support in real-time, practical
settings.

● Behavioral Growth During Recess: For children who exhibit behavioral challenges,
recess should be seen not as a privilege to be taken away but as an opportunity for
growth. Instead of excluding these children from recess, consider advocating for the
inclusion of support services during this time. An occupational therapist or a special
education teacher can work with the child on behavioral strategies directly within the
recess setting. This approach not only helps the child remain integrated with their peers
but also utilizes the natural environment of play to address and improve behavioral
issues effectively.

Constructive Alternatives to Withholding Recess

While recess is an essential part of the school day that should not be withheld, there are many
other constructive ways to address behavioral issues that promote learning and personal
growth. Here is a list of 20 actionable and educational alternative consequences that can be
implemented in educational settings, ensuring that students continue to benefit from their recess
time:

1. Environmental Responsibility: For littering, have the student help clean up a section of
the schoolyard.
2. Impact Essay: Students using inappropriate language can write essays on the power of
words and their impact.
3. Parental Involvement: For disruptive behavior, invite a parent to attend classes with the
child for a day.
4. Apology Letters: Have students write apology letters to affected parties, detailing their
actions and improvement plans.
5. Reflection Essay: Students who disrupt class could reflect on the importance of a
conducive classroom environment for learning.
6. Service Tasks: Assign tasks like organizing library books or assisting in the cafeteria to
contribute positively to the school community.
7. Peer Mediation: Engage students in peer mediation sessions to foster communication
and conflict resolution skills.
8. Creative Expression: Allow students to create posters or artwork expressing feelings or
teaching lessons about appropriate behaviors.
9. Behavior Contracts: Develop behavior contracts with students, outlining expected
behaviors and consequences.
10. Skill Building: Provide workshops on anger management or conflict resolution for
students exhibiting aggressive behavior.
11. School Service: Let students assist teachers or administration, fostering responsibility
and involvement in school operations.
12. Peer Teaching: Allow students to teach part of a lesson under supervision, which builds
confidence and responsibility.
13. Group Discussion: Encourage students to participate in discussions about community
and respect.
14. Educational Videos: Assign educational videos related to their behaviors with a
summary report on learnings.
15. Community Service: Encourage involvement in community service projects related to
the student’s behavior.
16. Mentorship Programs: Pair students with school mentors for guidance and support.
17. Public Speaking: Have students prepare and deliver presentations on relevant topics to
the class.
18. Behavior Reflection Forms: Use reflection forms for students to analyze their behavior
and potential improvements.
19. Time Management Workshop: Offer workshops on time management for those
struggling with punctuality or deadlines.
20. Cultural Awareness Activities: Engage students in activities that promote cultural
understanding and respect.

By employing these alternatives, schools can address behavioral issues constructively without
compromising a student’s right to recess, thereby supporting a comprehensive approach to
discipline that emphasizes growth and learning over punishment.

Communication Strategies: Ensuring Recess is Valued

Effective communication is essential in ensuring that the importance of recess is recognized and
respected within schools. Here are some strategies for engaging constructively with school staff
and administrators, underpinned by the rigorous documentation practices highlighted in
PASEN’s “IEP Documentation Strategies” blog post.

● Be Clear and Concise: Clearly articulate the benefits of recess for your child’s
development during discussions with teachers and administrators. Support your points
with specific examples and evidence from reputable sources, such as the benefits cited
in health and education research.

● Strategic Use of IEP Meetings: Utilize IEP or 504 meetings as opportunities to
emphasize the importance of recess. Prepare by reviewing the “IEP Documentation
Strategies” blog post on PASEN’s website, which provides detailed advice on
documenting meetings effectively to ensure your points are recorded accurately.

● Documentation and Follow-Up: Consistently document interactions and decisions
regarding recess in IEP or 504 meetings using strategies from the blog post, such as
taking detailed notes and employing the Prior Written Notice (PWN) when changes are
proposed. Follow up meetings with emails summarizing the discussions, ensuring a
written record aligns with what was agreed upon.

● Build Relationships and Engage: Participate in school events and volunteer to
establish and maintain positive relationships with school staff. These interactions provide
opportunities to informally discuss the importance of recess and your child’s needs.

● Leverage Parental Support: Engage with other parents through parent-teacher
associations or special education advisory groups. Collective advocacy can be more
influential in promoting the implementation of effective recess policies.

● Utilize Available Tools: Incorporate tools like the PWN Parent Tracker mentioned in the
PASEN blog post. This tool can help track and document school decisions regarding
recess, providing a clear record for advocacy and follow-up discussions.

Implementing these strategies and utilizing the detailed documentation practices advocated in
PASEN’s blog post can enhance your advocacy efforts. This ensures that recess is safeguarded
as an essential part of your child’s educational plan, reflecting its critical role in fostering social,
emotional, and physical development.

Advocating for Recess

Recess is a critical part of every student’s day, recognized widely for its role in enhancing
physical health, social skills, and academic performance. Understanding and using established
guidelines for recess can significantly strengthen advocacy efforts in educational settings.
Here’s how you can use these principles during IEP meetings and school board discussions:

Framework for IEP Recess Advocacy

● Recognize the Broad Benefits of Recess: Recess is acknowledged for its ability to
improve life skills such as cooperation, following rules, and effective communication.
These benefits extend to enhancing classroom behavior, including better attention and
memory. Advocates should emphasize these benefits to illustrate the comprehensive
value of recess beyond just physical activity.

● Assess Current Recess Policies and Practices: Start by understanding the existing
policies at your child’s school or within the district. Are there explicit policies about daily
recess? How long is recess? Who supervises it? Is there a contingency plan for bad
weather? This initial assessment helps identify advocacy points for improvement or
reinforcement.

● Advocate for Adequate and Safe Facilities: Ensure that all students have access to
safe and age-appropriate playgrounds or structured play areas. Advocacy can include
campaigning for necessary upgrades or maintenance to support active and engaging
recess times.

● Ensure Recess is Not Withheld as Punishment: Push for policies that protect recess
as a non-negotiable part of the school day. Recess should not be withheld for academic
or disciplinary reasons, as this contradicts its fundamental role in child development.
Strategies for Using These Principles in Advocacy

● IEP and 504 Plan Meetings: During IEP and 504 meetings, explicitly advocate for
recess as a crucial element of the educational plan. Use the broader understanding of
recess’s benefits to argue for its inclusion and protection in the educational setting.

● School Board Discussions: When engaging with school boards, present a
well-rounded argument for the importance of recess, backed by the acknowledged
benefits and the need for proper facilities. Advocate for specific policy changes or
confirmations that align with ensuring every student receives adequate recess time.

● Community Engagement: Mobilize other parents and community members by sharing
information on the benefits of recess and the need for structured policies. Encourage
community involvement in school meetings or through social media platforms to amplify
the call for consistent and beneficial recess practices.

By adopting these strategies and focusing on a comprehensive advocacy approach, you can
effectively champion the cause of recess in schools, ensuring that this crucial activity is
recognized and preserved as a fundamental part of every student’s educational experience.

Conclusion

In this post, we’ve explored the critical role of recess in promoting the holistic development
of children, especially those with disabilities. From its benefits to the challenges and legal
considerations surrounding its inclusion, we’ve delved into the multifaceted aspects of ensuring
every child has equitable access to recess. It’s evident that recess is not merely a break from
academic studies but an integral part of learning and socialization, fostering skills essential for
success both inside and outside the classroom.

As parents and advocates, it’s crucial to recognize the significance of proactive advocacy in
safeguarding recess as a non-negotiable part of every child’s educational plan. By following the
outlined strategies and leveraging legal protections, we can ensure that all children, regardless
of ability, have the opportunity to benefit from this vital aspect of the school day.

Remember, advocating for recess isn’t just about securing playtime—it’s about advocating for
the well-being, social development, and academic success of our children. Together, let’s
continue to champion recess advocacy, ensuring that every child receives the full spectrum of
benefits that recess offers.

References

1. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10319329/
2. https://www.cdc.gov/childrensmentalhealth/data.html
3. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/04/23/health/mental-health-crisis-teens.html
4. https://www.usnews.com/news/health-news/articles/2023-05-01/suicide-rates-among-u-s
-adolescents-doubled-in-10-years
5. https://www.apa.org/monitor/2022/10/child-anxiety-treatment
6. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6435492/
7. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10245370/
8. https://publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article/131/1/183/30893/The-Crucial-Role-of-Rece
ss-in-School?autologincheck=redirected
9. https://www.cdc.gov/healthyschools/physicalactivity/recess.htm
10. https://www.cdc.gov/healthyschools/physicalactivity/pdf/recess_data_brief_cdc_logo_fina
l_191106.pdf
11. https://www.cdc.gov/healthyschools/physicalactivity/pdf/Recess_All_Students.pdf
12. https://www.cdc.gov/healthyschools/physicalactivity/pdf/2019_04_25_SchoolRecess_str
ategies_508tagged.pdf
13. https://www.cdc.gov/healthyschools/parentsforhealthyschools/pdf/p4hs_recess.pdf
14. https://www.proquest.com/openview/0bd12ac4da425079371b8397409c9456/1?pq-origsi
te=gscholar&cbl=18750&diss=y
15. https://www.nih.gov/news-events/news-releases/study-shows-how-taking-short-breaks-m
ay-help-our-brains-learn-new-skills
10